The NFL offseason marks a crucial period for teams as they strategize to enhance their prospects for the upcoming season. While each move aims to bolster success, not all decisions stand the test of time, and some teams might eventually rue their choices.

This article delves into seven roster moves made during the 2023 offseason that currently raise doubts but possess the potential to transform into significant missteps by season’s end.

Arizona Cardinals’ Calculated Risk: Passing on Leftback Isaiah Simmons’ 5th-Year Extension

The Arizona Cardinals, under new leadership with a fresh general manager and head coach, made a consequential choice by opting not to exercise LB Isaiah Simmons’ fifth-year extension. While Simmons may not have fulfilled the high expectations typically associated with a top draft pick, he has displayed potential through notable defensive plays and impressive tackle numbers.

The Cardinals’ decision not to extend his contract beyond the 2023 season could potentially deprive them of a talented playmaker who could have been a contender for the Pro Bowl.

Baltimore Ravens: Risky Signing of WR Odell Beckham Jr.

The Baltimore Ravens showcased their daring side by securing WR Odell Beckham Jr. on a one-year contract worth $15 million. Despite Beckham’s previous reputation as one of the NFL’s premier receivers, concerns arise due to his recent injury troubles and underwhelming performance. With a track record of limited productivity in recent years, the Ravens may find themselves questioning the wisdom of this acquisition as time progresses.

Dallas Cowboys: Choosing DT Mazi Smith over TE Michael Mayer

During the offseason, the Dallas Cowboys confronted a pivotal choice in filling the vacancy created by the departure of tight end Dalton Schultz. Rather than selecting a highly productive and versatile tight end like Michael Mayer, the Cowboys chose to go with DT Mazi Smith. Although Smith may contribute to addressing defensive requirements, the decision to forgo a top-tier tight end might restrict the team’s offensive capabilities, particularly in the red zone.

Detroit Lions: Drafting RB Jahmyr Gibbs Over a Cornerback

The Detroit Lions raised eyebrows with their first-round pick, choosing RB Jahmyr Gibbs instead of addressing their cornerback need in their NFL DFS bets. While Gibbs has the potential to strengthen an already formidable backfield, the Lions missed an opportunity to reinforce their secondary, which struggled in the previous season.

The decision could leave them vulnerable to opposing quarterbacks exploiting their weak cornerback depth, leading the Lions to potentially regret passing on a defensive playmaker.

Kansas City Chiefs: Overpaying for OT Jawaan Taylor

The Kansas City Chiefs made a substantial commitment by inking offensive tackle Jawaan Taylor to a four-year, $80 million contract, with $60 million guaranteed. However, Taylor’s performance has been consistent rather than exceptional, as he has yet to deliver a standout season or secure Pro Bowl recognition. Given the substantial guaranteed money involved, the Chiefs could be viewed as having potentially overspent on an average offensive tackle.

Los Angeles Rams: Mistake in Cutting OLB Leonard Floyd

The Los Angeles Rams underwent a series of roster moves, signaling a transition toward a younger team, but the decision to release OLB Leonard Floyd could potentially be viewed as a misjudgment. Floyd showcased his prowess as a pass rusher, consistently tallying sacks and tackles for loss during his tenure with the Rams. Considering the team’s subpar pressure rate on defense, the Rams will be relying on their rookie replacement to swiftly step up and fill the void left by Floyd.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Trading G Shaq Mason

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers encountered salary cap limitations that necessitated difficult choices. Nevertheless, the potential repercussions of trading G Shaq Mason may lead to regret. Mason has established himself as a dependable starting guard, and the Buccaneers could have explored alternative methods, such as contract restructuring, to alleviate their cap situation. By parting ways with Mason, the Buccaneers run the risk of diminishing the strength of their offensive line and jeopardizing the protection of their quarterbacks.


In the ever-changing landscape of the NFL offseason, teams often make decisions that are met with skepticism. While some moves may turn out to be successful, others have the potential to become significant regrets. The seven roster moves discussed in this article highlight the questionable choices made by NFL teams in the 2023 off-season, raising doubts about their long-term impact. As the season progresses, it will become clear whether these moves were prudent or if they will haunt the teams involved.